Novel Planning

How to Outline a Novel: Three Methods and a Worked Example

You have a premise, a few scenes you can see clearly, and a worry that starting without a plan will cost you months. Planning too much costs months too. An outline is a tool for finding out what you do not know yet, and there are three useful ways to build one, each at a different level of detail.

Language

Three outlines for three kinds of question

Outlining methods differ mainly in how much they commit you to. The one-paragraph spine tells you what the book is about. A scene list tells you what happens. A chapter-by-chapter outline tells you where each piece sits in the manuscript. You can use one of them, or move through all three as the book firms up.

None is the correct way. Writers who plan heavily and writers who discover as they go both finish novels. What matters is choosing the amount of structure that answers the question that is stopping you today.

Method one: the one-paragraph spine

Write four to six sentences that carry the whole book: who wants what, what stands in the way, the turn halfway through that changes the problem, the price of the climax, and how it ends. The ending is not optional. A spine without an ending is a premise.

A template helps. Your main character wants a goal because of a reason. An opposing force stands in the way, for its own reason. Halfway through, a discovery or reversal changes what the story is about. At the end, your character wins, loses or settles for something else, and it costs a specific price.

Here is a spine for the mystery used in the example below. Nell Okafor wants to sell her late aunt's bakery and leave Tarn Hollow within a week. The town council wants the ledger she finds kept buried, and the sheriff helps them. Halfway through, she learns her aunt was paying someone, not being paid, which turns a murder into a secret. At the end she exposes the council chair, gives up her plan to leave, and pays with her place as a comfortable outsider.

Use the spine when you have an idea but no shape, or when a draft has gone soft and you need to remember what the book is for. It is quick enough to rewrite five times in an afternoon, which is exactly how to use it.

Method two: the scene list

A scene list is one line per scene, in order. Each line says who is in the scene, what they want, and what is different when it ends. If nothing is different, the scene is a candidate for cutting or merging.

Keep each line to around twenty words and resist writing dialogue or description. You are checking cause and effect: does scene seven happen because of scene six? Writers often find a gap in the middle, where three scenes of people discussing the problem stand in for an event. A list shows you that in an hour. A draft shows you in three months.

If you are unsure where to start, a scene list is a sensible default. It fixes the sequence without fixing the prose.

Method three: the chapter-by-chapter outline

Here you assign scenes to chapters and add a few sentences to each: the point of view, the setting, the emotional movement, what the reader learns. It is the heaviest of the three, and it earns its weight when you have complications to juggle, such as several viewpoints, parallel timelines, or a mystery that must release clues in a set order.

The cost is brittleness. A detailed plan for chapter twenty-two, written before chapter four exists, will be wrong. Give the first third of the book full chapter detail and leave the rest at scene-list level until you get there.

How to pick one

Ask what is stopping you right now, then choose the lightest method that answers it.

  • Choose the spine if you do not know what the book is about, or if you tend to abandon drafts in the middle.
  • Choose the scene list if you know the story but cannot see the order, or you want to find holes before drafting.
  • Choose the chapter outline if you have several viewpoints, a timeline puzzle, or clues that must land in sequence.
  • When unsure, write the spine first, then a scene list for the stretch you are about to draft.

A worked example: a 12-line scene list

Here is a scene list for an invented small-town mystery. Nell Okafor returns to Tarn Hollow to sell the bakery she inherited from her aunt Odile, who died in a fall at the old mill. Each line gives the scene, then what changes.

Notice what the list reveals. The midpoint in line six turns the question from who killed Odile into what Odile was paying for. Nobody planned that turn at the start; it appeared because line five needed a reason for the break-in. That is the kind of discovery a list makes cheap.

  • 1. Arrival: Nell reaches Tarn Hollow in the rain, and Sheriff Pruitt is oddly eager to help with the sale. Change: she plans a quick exit and notices his eagerness.
  • 2. The pantry: she finds a ledger of initials and sums in a flour bin, in Odile's hand. Change: the quick sale is off.
  • 3. The apprentice: Tobias claims to know nothing about it and is wearing Odile's watch. Change: she has her first lie to chase.
  • 4. The diner: she hears Odile fell from the mill stairs, and Dr. Ansel will not meet her eye about the time of death. Change: the fall looks wrong.
  • 5. The council list: the initials match four members of the town council. Change: she knows who was involved, not why.
  • 6. The break-in: someone searches the bakery, but Nell has hidden the ledger. She reads it again and sees Odile was the one paying. Change: Odile was not a blackmailer; the story turns from a murder to a secret she was buying.
  • 7. Tobias breaks: he says Odile gave him the watch to hide the night she died because she was afraid. Change: Nell learns the death was expected.
  • 8. The doctor: Dr. Ansel admits she signed the certificate under pressure from Pruitt. Change: the sheriff is now a suspect.
  • 9. The old fire: the sums trace to a mill fire twenty years ago and a watchman who died when the sprinklers were switched off. Change: the secret has a body.
  • 10. The sheriff cornered: Pruitt confesses to covering up out of fear, not murder, and names council chair Marguerite Hale. Change: the suspect swaps.
  • 11. Dawn at the bakery: Nell uses Odile's last ledger entry to make Hale admit she pushed Odile. Change: the truth is spoken aloud with a witness.
  • 12. Afterward: Nell gives the ledger to a state investigator, keeps the bakery open, and finds Tobias at the ovens. Change: she stays.

When to stop outlining

Stop when you can start the next scene without guessing what it is for. You do not need a finished map, only the next stretch and a direction for the ending. These are signs you have gone past that point:

  • You are polishing sentences inside the outline.
  • You keep adding backstory instead of events.
  • Weeks have passed and no scene has been drafted.
  • The story feels already told, and drafting seems dull.

If you write to discover the story, outline backward instead. After each session, write two lines saying what happened and what you now expect next. You end up with a scene list built from the draft, and it protects you from losing threads you planted by accident.

Changing the outline as the draft teaches you

The draft will disagree with the outline. A character will refuse a scene, a minor figure will turn out to matter, and your midpoint may arrive a quarter of the way in. That is the outline doing its job: it was a hypothesis, and the draft is the test.

When it happens, revise forward. Rewrite only the lines after the change, and keep a short note at the top saying what changed and why, so you can undo it. If you decide Tobias should break in scene 5 rather than scene 7, recheck scenes 6 to 12 for anything that depended on his silence.

In SagaFold you can keep clues and characters as story notes linked to the passages where they appear, so you can see every place a clue lives before you move it, and you can try a rewritten scene as an alternate draft before replacing the original.